Southend United v Peterborough United

Southend United v Peterborough United

Commentary By: Andy Martin

FINAL SCORE: 2 - 1



GOODBYE

AM at 2015-09-05 14:31:06

Many thanks for your interactive comments this afternoon and apologies again for the loss of coverage during the first half.

Have a good weekend and don’t forget to tune in tomorrow at 2.30pm to have another look at a referee (Peter Banks) who is also in the development group.

Kind regards

Andy Martin


HACKETTS BLOG

AM at 2015-09-05 14:28:31

‘Hackett’s Blog’ the former Head of Referees at the PGMOL and top referee looks daily with the latest news, views and honest comment:

Keep up to date with the latest current topics of debate and discussion.

 


THE REF SHOW

AM at 2015-09-05 14:25:50

Tune in to this week’s The Ref Show Part 1 & 2 where we have Alan Biggs in the chair who always gets to the heart of the matter by his unique probing and subtle asking of questions from our experts Mark Halsey and Glenn Turner. Alan Biggs, Mark Halsey and Glenn Turner of You Are The Ref discuss how referees prepare for games, the competition to win a signed referee shirt, and relive some embarrassing moments. YATR is all about education and training of match officials and also those interested in refereeing decisions and key moments during Matches. The discussions that occur from these key match incidents and all about gaining knowledge, skills and improving performance and there is no other refereeing web site better equipped than us to deliver this fantastic product!

 

As always, YATR values your opinions on all the points raised by out experts via Twitter @youaretheref or email us at Info@you-are-the-ref.com


UP AND COMING GAMES ON YATR

AM at 2015-09-05 14:24:55

RefCam has many more games lined up for September including tomorrow when we see Burton v Coventry with a 2.30pm kick off. Peter Banks will be refereeing and he is also in the development group.

Back to Premiership action next weekend when we see Everton v Chelsea with a 12.45pm ko and to conclude the day we see Manchester United v Liverpool with a 5.30pm ko.

A list of all the big games coming up on YATR is always available at: http://you-are-the-ref.com/ref-cam/


FULL TIME SUMMARY

AM at 2015-09-05 14:23:10

Match Summary –

Overall this match has been controlled and it is fair to say that the referee has managed the players in a positive way throughout.

Brief summary first half –

9th minute no penalty to Southend – a narrow angle adopted by SH to view no penalty given and viewing replays looked correct

12th minute clear shove by 12 P. on 9 S. no free kick awarded just outside of P. defending penalty area – SH was a long way from play unable to judge and his AR close to the incident did not advise either. Replays confirm that this was a clear foul by Santos and a resulting free kick should have been awarded to S.

15th non offside flag from JO`B correct against S. although replays support a handball from a S. player difficult for the referee to see from his view behind play.

24 KMI – Barrett of S. has clearly held down Santos of P. from a ck to P. My view here is that SH did not have the best view angle to detect this and this is my main area of development for SH to work at obtaining the optimum viewing angle coupled with acceleration and sprint work to enable him to keep up with play to be in the best position to judge the key match incidents.

In the 2nd half we saw correct yellow cards shown and SH was consistent in this area only to miss Timlin`s reckless challenge in the 71t minute when no yellow card was shown. This was a mandatory yellow card and I was surprised that one was not shown.

Mobility,movement and acceleration are areas for SH to work at as this will help in him creating viewing angles to judge incidents as I have mentioned in my BLOG.

Both ARs gave good solid support and with regards to offside there were a number of good non offside flags when players were level and no offside flag therefore correctly not raised.

 

 


FULL TIME

AM at 2015-09-05 14:00:04

FULL TIME IS 2-1


90+4

AM at 2015-09-05 13:59:36

SH blows his whistle for full time as the ball is played into the Southend defending penalty area, fortunately the ball is blocked by players and does become a goal bound effort. Always best to ensure safety before you blow your whistle for half/full time


90+3

AM at 2015-09-05 13:57:18

FK to P. defensive retaken as SH ensures correct restart


90+1

AM at 2015-09-05 13:56:04

As Peterborough make a quick break, the ball goes over the bar as they search an equaliser. Advantage to P. on the half way line. SH remains there  (with players in case of retribution) as play breaks away leaving him stranded for any key decision to be made


90

am at 2015-09-05 13:53:33

Goal for PETERBOROUGH – 2-1 –  Southend make another sub 9 off 24 on


88

AM at 2015-09-05 13:51:52

Advantage to Peterborough which allows a good clear attack to develop, good signal seen from SH


87

AM at 2015-09-05 13:49:48

Southend sub 7 off and 17 on a change in formation of play will now be seen as Southend look to hold onto their lead


85

AM at 2015-09-05 13:48:15

Free kick to Southend which the referee awards from some distance and then turns his back on the all players behind him on the half way line. It is always best to remain focussed and have the players in view


84

AM at 2015-09-05 13:46:31

SUB 16 OFF 23 ON FOR SOUTHEND


81

AM at 2015-09-05 13:45:49

Offside Southend from AY

17 off and 9 on defender off and striker on, this will change the pattern of play for Peterborough and the referee will need to be aware


80

AM at 2015-09-05 13:43:48

In my full time match summary I will cover briefly the first half which was missed due to technical problems


77

AM at 2015-09-05 13:42:00

Let us know what you think by contacting us on either on Twitter @youaretheref or email us at Info@you-are-the-ref.com

Feel free to interact with me during the game by joining in on Twitter @youaretheref or e-mail at info@you-are-the-ref.com

What were your thoughts on Timlin`s challenge?


71

AM at 2015-09-05 13:37:23

8 of Southend commits a reckless tackle and no yellow card is shown? instead SH speaks to 8 of Southend and the Peterborough player who must have certainly felt aggrieved at the challenge, I am sure the 4th Official would of had a good view as it was right in front of him, he could of offered the referee advice if he was unsure.


70

AM at 2015-09-05 13:34:34

Ball just goes out of play and JO`B is there to judge

8 Peterborough yellow card correct as he breaks up a positive attacking move from Southend.

Free kick to Southend,  and we have a goal 2-0 to Southend and I cannot see the use of the spray?


66

AM at 2015-09-05 13:30:37

Corner kick to Peterborough at these corner kicks just have a look at SH`s body language I would just like to see him look a bit more dynamic and show more movement coupled with the player movements and patterns of marking, you have to be on the move and cannot remain static in your positioning


64

AM at 2015-09-05 13:27:21

18 Southend yellow card – simulation correct and a good judgement from SH

19 off 28 on for Peterborough sub


62

AM at 2015-09-05 13:25:09

A good non offside flag from JO`B as Peterborough player level and therefore onside


60

AM at 2015-09-05 13:23:45

Simon Hooper today`s referee was born in Wiltshire and so far this season has refereed 6 games to date. One Premier League game to date with Simon`s first appointment of the season being Norwich 1 v Crystal Palace 3 with the major key incident in this game being to disallow a perfectly good goal for Norwich which has been the subject of much debate. One yellow card was shown in this game. Since this game Simon has refereed 5 Football League Games showing a total of 10 yellow and no red cards to date.

 

Southend United v Peterborough United and according to Phil Brown Southend`s Manager “we are close to our first victory this season” The Shrimpers currently are 20th in Division 1 with 3 points from 5 matches so far. Southend have lost all 3 matches that they have played at Roots Hall this season in all competitions and have fialed to score a goal can all this change today?

 

As for Peterborough Manager Dave Robertson after a spell as Caretaker Manager took full time charge in the summer and they lost on Tuesday Night in the Johnstone`s Paint Trophy 1-0 @ Millwall. The loss means that The Posh have only won 3 of their last 16 games. 4 points from their opening 5 games so far this season.

A lot at stake therefore for both sides so early in the season and points becoming crucial for different reasons. As one Premier League Manager recently said “It is not about how you start or how you do in the middle of the season, it is all about how you end the season” ! try telling that to today`s managers, spectators and players.


58

AM at 2015-09-05 13:21:09

Feel free to interact with me during the game by joining in on Twitter @youaretheref or e-mail at info@you-are-the-ref.com


57

AM at 2015-09-05 13:20:32

A quick breakaway to Southend does see SH working hard to get into the best viewing angle to create the best view for those key match decisions in the penalty area


55

AM at 2015-09-05 13:19:05

Corner kick to Peterborough followed by another, SH does tend to be very static at these c/ks with little or no movement to adjust his viewing position / angle as players move their position


54

AM at 2015-09-05 13:16:48

A great effort from Peterborough hits the bar and rebounds to safety. Offside from Alan Young who is assisting on the Technical Area touchline


52

AM at 2015-09-05 13:15:27

Advantage played by SH in the middle of the field of play tight but it has worked for him


51

AM at 2015-09-05 13:14:26

The Match Officials selected by the PGMOL Management Team for this afternoon`s game are as follows:

 

Referee: Simon Hooper (SH)

AR1: John O`Brien (JO`B)

AR2: Alan Young (AY)

4th Official: Tim Robinson (TS)


50

AM at 2015-09-05 13:13:24

The main talking point from the 1st half was the non award of a penalty kick to Peterborough in the 24th minute following a corner kick to Peterborough.

Barrett of Southend has clearly held down and grabbed the shirt of Santos of Peterborough. No penalty kick was awarded and I felt that the static position of the referee and poor positioning / viewing angle did not detect this foul and therefore penalty award.


46

AM at 2015-09-05 13:09:39

Welcome to the 2nd half of this game and apologies for technical problems for missing the 1st half of LIVE REF CAM coverage.